Taxes – The Trickle-Down-Myth

Myths are when people irrationally believe in something that isn’t real. An example from the tax-economy is the trickle-down-effect. In simple terms, the trickle-down-effect is when rich people invest money that they don’t pay as taxes, in the economy, which then creates as least as many jobs, as if the state had collected that money and invested itself. The idea is that this money is spent by the rich at the top and then trickles down even to the very poor at the bottom. A wonderful argument for promoting tax cuts for rich people. The problem? It doesn’t actually happen. During economic booms, the poor got richer but the rich got even more quickly even wealthier. During crisis, well the poor lost way more than the rich. Overall income inequality grew stronger and the median-income in the US actually decreased since the seventies. Fact is: The additional wealth favors mainly the already wealthy and there are next to no drops trickling down.

Noteworthy! Every tax-cutter dreams about all the investments the rich would do, if only the government would let them more money. But this claim is not backed-up by evidence and I think it’s not even rational to assume. Let’s say a rich person, which already has virtually everything he can think of buying, instantly has more money at his disposal, what is he likely to do? Most probably he goes to see his bank manager (so at least he creates a job at a bank). The rest of the money he will probably invest in some emerging market without creating any extra-jobs in his home country. Obviously, he is going to invest where business outlook is good, not in his crisis riddled home country. Now, think the state takes some money away from this rich person and give it to 100 poor jobless persons. What are they going to do? They get some new shoes, maybe they go to the cinema or make a trip to a leisure park. That money is almost certainly spent at home for activities and goods that wouldn’t be bought otherwise.

This is a somewhat simple but not necessarily wrong wrap-up. Fact is, the big majority has an interest that rich people pay a bit more taxes. Unless, of course, the majority plans to get rich itself and accordingly votes as if they had already won a lottery – against their core-interests.

Source: Foreign Policy

Related Posts:

There are no comments yet. Be the first and leave a response!

Leave a Reply

Wanting to leave an <em>phasis on your comment?

Trackback URL http://www.noteworthy.ch/economy/taxes-the-trickle-down-myth/trackback/